David KrauseDEEN Knowledge Base · Part IV · Chapter 9
Part IV — Quotation costing Chapter 9 / 18 Reading path method selection Edition v23.2 · 10/2026

Which costing method fits?

Four methods, one decision. When a differentiated overhead surcharge is enough and when the machine hour rate becomes indispensable is decided by a single figure — the machine cost share per cost center.

30 %
machine cost share · the threshold
3.7×
spread · cheapest to dearest machine
74 %
rate spread · assembly vs. 5-axis

9.1 The four methods

MethodPrincipleSuited toLimit
Division costingtotal cost / quantityone product, mass productionfails with variants
Equivalence figuresconvert variants via ratio numbersbatch production with proportional differencesthe ratio must be stable
Surcharge costingoverhead as a percentage on direct costssingle-part and small-series productiondistorts with unequal cost centers
Machine hour ratemachine costs per hour, remainder as surchargecapital-intensive production with differing assetshigher recording effort

9.2 When does introducing the MHR pay off?

Machine-hour-rate costing is more involved than a blanket surcharge. It pays off as soon as the cost centers differ markedly — and that is precisely the rule in machining.

Hourly rates in the reference company
Cost centerMHRSurchargeFull hour rate
200 · CNC turning€20.13/MH39.8 % RGK€64.87/h
210 · CNC 5-axis milling€46.37/MH35.1 % RGK€89.60/h
240 · assembly—60.8 % FGK€51.46/h

The table shows both in the same company: the machine cost centers run via the MHR, assembly deliberately stays on the differentiated FGK surcharge (60.8 %). That is not a contradiction but the correct allocation — each center is charged via the quantity that drives its costs.

9.3 Differentiated FGK surcharge or MHR?

Not every company needs machine hour rates. A company with differentiated FGK surcharges — its own percentage per cost center — is far ahead of the blanket surcharge and can be entirely sufficient for labor-intensive production. The decision hangs on a single figure: the machine cost share per center.

Cost center situationRight methodWhy
Labor-intensive, low machine tie-up (assembly, welding, inspection)differentiated FGK surchargeoverhead follows personnel deployment — the labor reference is correct
Mixed, machine cost share < 30 %differentiated FGK surcharge sufficesdistortion from the labor reference stays within tolerance
Machine cost share > 30 %, homogeneous parkMHR per center groupone rate for similar machines is enough, effort manageable
Machine cost share > 30 %, heterogeneous parkMHR per machine/cost centeronly the individual MHR captures the large rate differences (see 9.5)
The most common error with the differentiated surcharge

A differentiated FGK rate becomes dangerous when applied to a capital-intensive center whose machine costs do not correlate with labor. Example: an automated turning center runs unmanned — little direct labor, high machine costs. An FGK surcharge "on labor" charges far too little overhead there, because the reference base (labor) is small while the actual costs (machine) are large. Exactly this case demands the MHR — the differentiated surcharge cannot catch it.

9.4 Decision matrix: which method?

Answer the criteria and choose the method with the most hits for your situation. ★ = especially suited.

CriterionBlanketArea-basedCC-basedMHR ★
< 10 employees✓✓
10–30 employees✓✓✓
> 30 employees✓✓
Homogeneous machine park✓✓✓
Heterogeneous park (CNC, die casting, assembly)✓
Machine costs > 30 % of manufacturing costs✓✓
Single-part / small-series production✓✓✓✓

9.5 Four machine types in MHR comparison

The same methodology from Chapter 7 (replacement-value basis, technical service life, OEE productive hours, six cost components), applied to four real asset types — directly comparable.

MachineRVSLhprodΣ €/yearMHR €/MH
Injection molder 250 t (3-shift)€215k12 yr4,609€70,20215.24
CNC 5-axis machining center (2-shift)€410k10 yr2,819€96,04034.07
Die casting (Al, 2-shift)€520k9 yr3,100€148,00047.74
Laser cutting system (2-shift)€580k8 yr3,254€181,90055.90

The factor of 3.7 between the cheapest and dearest machine shows why a blanket rate necessarily cross-subsidizes in a mixed park.

The rule of thumb

If the full hour rates of the manufacturing centers differ by more than about 20 percent, a blanket surcharge is no longer defensible. In the reference company, 74 percent lie between assembly and 5-axis milling — here a blanket rate would be grossly negligent. For three similar turning machines, by contrast, a common rate suffices.

9.6 Activity-based costing: when it pays off

The four methods above allocate the costs of production. The indirect areas — purchasing, work preparation, design, order processing — still run through percentage surcharges. That is acceptable as long as these areas are small and all orders use them in a similar way. Where that no longer holds, the surcharge distorts: it allocates by value, but the work arises per transaction.

Purchasing example · purchasing and goods receipt €54,000/year, 1,800 order lines = €30 per line
Purchase orderMaterial valueSurcharge 9 %Activity cost rate
100 titanium blanks, one line€8,500€765.00€30.00
20 standard parts, one line€40€3.60€30.00
What the table shows

Both orders cause the same effort: request, order, book goods receipt, check the invoice. The surcharge loads the expensive material with 25 times that effort and the cheap one with an eighth of it. Expensive material subsidizes small orders — visible in the quotation price, invisible in its cause.

When to introduce it, when not

It pays off as soon as the indirect areas make up a large share of costs and orders use them very differently: variant production, special-purpose machinery and plant engineering, companies with many small orders. There the design or order-processing hour is the real cost driver, not the machine hour.

It does not pay off as a company-wide system in a contract manufacturer with few indirect staff. A side calculation for one or two activities — cost per order line, per quotation, per set-up — alongside surcharge and machine hour rate costing is enough.

Target costing starts at the other end — with the price set by the market or the customer. When it works for manufacturing companies and where the job shop reaches its limit is shown in 9.7.

9.7 Target costing: from the target price back to costs

All methods so far calculate forwards: costs plus markup give the price. Target costing calculates backwards. The market or the customer names the price; after deducting the target margin, the allowable costs remain. The difference to your own costs (drifting costs) is the target cost gap — it has to be closed in design, material or process before the part goes into production.

Target costing · titanium housing from Chapter 11 Customer target price: €160.00
Allowable costs at 15 % profit on full cost (as in ch. 11): 160.00 / 1.15 = €139.13
Own full cost (ch. 11): €158.93

Target cost gap: 158.93 − 139.13 = €19.80 per unit = 12.5 %
0 30 60 90 120 150 180 €/unit customer target price €160.00 − target profit 15% on cost €20.87 = allowable costs €139.13 own full cost (drifting) €158.93 target cost gap €19.80 of which variable costs €121.91
Fig. 9.1 · Target costing titanium housing · target price €160 vs. full cost €158.93
Where the gap can be closed · full cost €158.93 by cost block (ch. 13.2)
Cost block€/unitshareLeverJob shop
Material Ti6Al4V incl. material overhead92.6558 %near-net-shape blank, material, sourceonly with customer approval
Machine (MHR variable + fixed)15.7710 %occupancy time: −0.06 h = −€2.78yes — own process
Labor, CAM, residual overhead14.529 %multi-machine operation (16.3)yes
Special direct costs12.508 %depreciate fixture over a framework quantityyes, with volume commitment
Administration, sales23.4915 %none in the short runno
Full cost158.93100 %
If the gap stays open

On its own, a job shop only reaches machine, labor and special direct costs — together €42.79 per unit, realistically a fraction of that. If a gap remains, contribution margin accounting decides: €160 is above the variable costs of €121.91, the contribution margin is €38.09. As an additional order with free capacity the price is acceptable (13.4). As the price for the entire volume it is not: break-even would be 11,106 units, 111 % of capacity (13.5).

When target costing fits a manufacturing company
Company typeTarget costingForm
Series manufacturer with own developmentyes, fullytarget cost splitting onto functions and assemblies before the design is fixed
Supplier with design responsibilityyescustomer target price as a given, design-to-cost, agreed annual price reductions built in
Job shop working to customer drawingslimitedbackward calculation against the target price, levers in the own process, design only via change proposals
One-off and special production without a market pricenoquotation costing (ch. 10)
The limit of this book

Actual target cost splitting — distributing allowable costs over functions and components by customer value — requires design authority and belongs in product development. For the job shop the backward calculation above is enough: in five minutes it shows whether a target price is reachable and which cost block would have to move.

David Krause
Industrial engineer (Dipl.-Wirtschaftsingenieur FH) · 15+ years of cost accounting, plant controlling and maintenance in CNC and die-casting manufacturing. Writes down here what has proven itself in practice.
Profile and CV · Knowledge Base · Contact