Which system for which question?
Full costs tell you what it costs. Partial costs tell you whether it is worthwhile. Activity-based costs tell you why it costs so much. Target costing tells you what it may cost.
| System | Question it answers | Horizon | Cost basis | Recommended when | Typical mistake |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full costing Ch. 5–7, 10 | What does it cost — and what price do I need in the long run? | long-term | full cost | series prices, quotations, inventory valuation | used for one-off decisions |
| Partial costing (contribution margin) Ch. 13 | Is it worthwhile now — and does the sum of contribution margins cover fixed costs? | short-term per order; per period as fixed-cost coverage | partial cost | additional order, make-or-buy, bottleneck, product mix | variable costs used as a permanent price, coverage budget not checked |
| Activity-based costing Ch. 9.6 | Who drives the overhead: variants, small orders, quotations, purchase orders? | medium-term | full cost | large indirect areas, many variants and small orders | introduced although the indirect areas are small |
| Flexible standard costing Ch. 5.10 | Who is responsible for the variance: shop floor or utilization? | period | full cost | budget with plan-actual comparison, inventory at full cost | consumption and volume mixed up |
| Marginal standard costing Ch. 5.11 | What does one hour more or less cost — and where does the shop floor overspend? | period | partial cost | high fixed-cost share, fluctuating utilization, monthly steering | no full-cost parallel calculation for price and balance sheet |
| Target costing Ch. 9.7 | What may the part cost if the price is fixed? | life cycle | market-driven | own development or target price from the customer | target cost gap closed by discount instead of by cost |
Every cost has an expiry date. Variable costs expire with the order, fixed costs with the contract. Every system freezes a time horizon — the question is whether it fits your decision. Chapter 13.8
Example companies: where each system fits
Typical company types, not real companies. Headcounts and shares are rules of thumb for orientation.
- Characteristics
- One-offs and small batches to customer drawings, every enquiry a separate quotation.
- Why it fits
- Every quotation needs full cost per machine hour, and inventory is valued at production cost.
- Fails when
- utilization collapses and the rates are pushed up — the death spiral from 13.5.
- Characteristics
- Typically over 60 % fixed costs, fluctuating utilization, frequent requests for extra lots, one large machine as the bottleneck.
- Why it fits
- Additional orders, make-or-buy and the ranking at the bottleneck can only be decided correctly with variable costs.
- Fails when
- exception prices become the regular price and nobody checks the coverage budget.
- Characteristics
- Many small orders, large back office; the indirect areas carry a large share of costs.
- Why it fits
- Costs arise per purchase order, quotation and set-up — not per machine hour.
- Fails when
- the company has only a few indirect staff: then the effort exceeds the benefit.
- Characteristics
- Annual budget, cost center managers with accountability, semi-finished goods in stock.
- Why it fits
- The plan-actual comparison per cost center separates what the shop floor owns (spending) from what sales owns (volume).
- Fails when
- fixed and variable costs are not cleanly separated.
- Characteristics
- Three shifts, ERP with controlling module, monthly reporting, fluctuating call-offs from carmakers.
- Why it fits
- With a high fixed-cost share, the planned marginal cost basis decides correctly, and no volume variance distorts the shop-floor figures.
- Fails when
- no full costing runs in parallel — then quoted prices and the balance sheet are wrong.
- Characteristics
- Market price given, own design, product cycles of several years.
- Why it fits
- Costs are largely fixed in development; target cost splitting acts before anything is built.
- Fails when
- a job shop without design authority applies it — there the backward calculation is enough.
Three ways in
Table of contents
Every chapter works through the same company — Präzisionsteile Muster GmbH, a fictional CNC contract manufacturer. Every figure has an origin, every chain closes.
Part I · Fundamentals Chapters 1–3≈ 14 min
- Ch 01Why accounting isn't enoughFinancial accounting tells you what the year brought — not what a part costs4 min
- Ch 02The three-stage modelWhich costs? Where incurred? What for? Three questions, three stages — each building on the last4 min
- Ch 03The ten most expensive costing errorsTen recurring costing errors that push hour rates 15–35 % off reality — each with a worked example in euros6 min
Part II · Cost-type accounting Chapter 4≈ 9 min
- Ch 04From income statement to cost-type planSubject and imputed reconciliation: the four cost categories, what the P&L conceals, and the 24-node cost-type plan for …Tool: Abgrenzungs-Mapper9 min
Part III · Capacity & hour rate Chapters 5–8≈ 32 min
- Ch 05The cost center accounting sheetWhere overhead is incurred and at what rate it returns to costing10 min
- Ch 06Machine hour rate: the fundamentalsSeparating machine cost from labor cost, the six cost components, replacement value as the depreciation base, and why …9 min
- Ch 07Machine hour rate: step by stepA complete MHR calculation in five steps — from replacement value through productive hours to €46.37/MH, with sensitivity …8 min
- Ch 08Self-diagnosis and correction calculationsTen questions to your own costing. Each 'no' flags a correction need with a concrete euro figure — derived from the methods of …Tool: Self-test5 min
Part IV · Quotation costing Chapters 9–12≈ 25 min
- Ch 09Which costing method fits?Four costing methods, one decision: when a differentiated overhead surcharge is enough and when the machine hour rate becomes …5 min
- Ch 10The costing schemeSeven positions from material to invoice price: the full costing scheme on one order, including the lot-size effect and the …7 min
- Ch 11Three case studiesThe costing scheme applied to CNC titanium milling, plastic injection molding and aluminum die casting — each with its own …6 min
- Ch 12Post-calculation: the plan-actual comparisonWhere the pre-calculation was off and what it cost: plan-actual on the titanium order, variance causes systematized, and the …7 min
Part V · Steering & decisions Chapters 13–17≈ 22 min
- Ch 13Contribution margin accountingSplitting cost into variable and fixed answers what full costing cannot: orders below total cost, make-or-buy, break-even …8 min
- Ch 14Spindle time instead of machine timeA machine is occupied far longer than its spindle turns. Two views of one machine: the costing rate for quotes, the spindle …4 min
- Ch 15Recording tooling costs correctlyFour maturity levels of tool costing, the cost per spindle hour, the regrind posting rule and the scrap credit that quietly …3 min
- Ch 16Shift models and labor costThe shift model changes the labor rate — and the machine hour rate the other way4 min
- Ch 17Recording planning and CAM costsDirect cost or overhead? The CAM hour rate at full cost, and the lot-size effect that makes programming nearly a third of unit …3 min
Part VI · Digitalization Chapter 18≈ 5 min
- Ch 18Digitalizing cost accountingLocal AI in cost accounting: rule before model, three sensible use cases, an ROI that amortizes in under 2.3 months, and why …5 min
Specialist articles
Twelve deep-dives in four topics — each linked to the chapter it builds on.
- Measuring OEE, TEEP and labor productivity correctlyThree metrics that are often confused — and one calculation few people make: what does a percentage point of loss cost?7 min · builds on Ch 7
- Calculating maintenance intervals, not guessing themMaintenance intervals worth calculating, not guessing: how the Weibull shape parameter picks the strategy — and why …8 min · builds on Ch 6
- Repair or replace: costing the replacement investmentOverhaul or new machine: annual costs with annuity and residual value — and why utilization decides.4 min · builds on Ch 7
- Costing scrap and rework correctlyWhy the scrap surcharge is 1/(1−q) and not q, why the moment of detection sets its size, and why rework must be carried separately5 min · builds on Ch 10
- Toll machining and free-issue materialThe customer supplies the material, we only machine. Why the contribution-margin ratio misleads and the margin per bottleneck …5 min · builds on Ch 13
- Project costing and cost forecastConcurrent costing in project business: actuals plus commitments plus estimate to complete — seeing the overrun while there is still time to steer.4 min · builds on Ch 12
- Buying cutting tools by cost per partWhy the more expensive cutter is often the cheaper one: price, tool life, change time and machine hour rate in one figure.4 min · builds on Ch 15
- The monthly report on one pagePlan-actual with variance commentary: five key figures, spending and volume variance separated, one action with owner and date.4 min · builds on Ch 5
- ROIC: What the capital in a plant actually earnsReturn on invested capital from a controller's perspective: how ROIC is calculated, why it only becomes meaningful against the …7 min · builds on Ch 13
- The yield curve and the imputed interest rateWhere the interest rate in cost accounting comes from: how the yield curve grounds the imputed rate — and how a rate shift …9 min · builds on Ch 6
- Book value and economic value — the replacement-value parallelWhy book value misses true worth — for an intangible asset as for a machine7 min · builds on Ch 6
- Local language models in cost accountingRule before model, baseline before model: how small, local models assign accounts — with a CostEngine case study13 min · builds on Ch 18
Tools
Calculate instead of read — all four run in the browser, no sign-up, no data transfer.
- Self-test: where does your costing stand?10 questions with live evaluation and a euro figure for each gapbelongs to chapter 8
- Abgrenzungs-Mapper (German)Map a DATEV trial balance to the 24-node cost-type reconciliationbelongs to chapter 4
- ROIC calculatorReturn on capital, economic profit and the effect of an investmentbelongs to the ROIC article · chapters 6 and 13
- Cost curves and price floorsBreak-even, special order, price erosion, step-fixed costs and bottleneck with your own figuresbelongs to chapter 13
All content comes from first-hand professional practice and the author's own records. Material from employment relationships stays confidential — only general expertise appears here, rewritten and worked through on the fictional reference company. Forecasting errors are documented rather than deleted.
